The controversy of huckleberry finn essay
Huckleberry finn criticism articles
Unable to utter the taboo word "nigger," students would be paralyzed, the whites by their social awareness of the moral injunction against it and the blacks by their heightened sensitivity to it. Far from demonstrating Jim's inferior knowledge, the debate dramatizes his argumentative superiority, and in doing so makes a serious ideological point through a rhetoric of humor. Even though the book or play is written by a Negro, they still do not like it. The Struggle for Tolerance by Peaches Henry. According to the committee that directed the study, the collected data indicated "that the elements of satire which are crucial to an understanding of the novel go largely unobserved by students. Considering the perplexity of the evasion brings us back full circle to Huckleberry Finn's suitability for public schools. It must be remembered that Huck does not adjudge slavery to be wrong; he selectively disregards a system that he ultimately believes is right. In addition, Twain uses lifestyles of African Americans Most of the academic criticisms written by Mark Twain masterpiece Huckleberry Finn are analyzing the explanation of the novel and the attitude toward racial discrimination and racial discrimination. The basis of this controversy can be summarized briefly for it was the use of racial slur and issues of slavery that caused tension in our society. Further, they charge that in order to entertain his white audience, Twain relied upon the stock conventions of "black minstrelsy," which "drew upon European traditions of using the mask of blackness to mock individuals or social forces. Some people argue that Huckleberry Finn is a racist work, and that the novel has no place in a highschool classroom. I had also expected the novel to be full of adventure and entertainment, but the thing I did not know was that it dealt with the arguable issue of slavery Any type of essay. The discontent with the racial attitudes of Huck Finn that began in has surfaced periodically over the past thirty years. Sculley Bradley et al.
Among the wide range of critics who clearly articulate a critical attitude towards Huck Finn may also be listed Forrest G. Given the powerlessness of highly discerning readers to resolve the novel in a way that unambiguously redeems Jim or Huck, how can students be expected to fare better with the novel's conclusion?
I wanted to sink into my seat. Since Huck Finn settled south before the slave made a white civil war, the use of the term currently considered politically correct is completely incorrect. Parents question the advisability of teaching to junior and senior high school students a text which requires such sophisticated interpretation in order for its moral statements to come clear.
Huck's entrenchment in the English curricula of junior and senior high schools coincided with Brown vs.
Why is the teaching and reading of huck finn so controversial?
Still, this novel has been the object of controversy since it was published more than years ago. Trilling's and Eliot's resounding endorsements provided Huck with the academic respectability and clout that assured his admission into America's classrooms. When we move from the context into which we want to deposit Huckleberry Finn and consider the nature of the text and its creator, matter becomes even more entangled. Several boards of education followed and adapted versions replacing the original one, featured with less violent tone, a more simplified southern dialect or a censorship on terms which described African Americans as inferior in any way. The character of Jim is most immediately portrayed as a stereotypically unintelligent, grotesque figure, and the novel itself ends with his capture and reenslavement. Although some believe that Mark Twains' novel perpetuates racist feelings, in fact Twain uses the characters to demonstrate the immorality of slavery. I try to love everybody. Racial Discourse 3. In the Philadelphia Board of Education, after removing Huck Finn, replaced it with an adapted version which "tone[d] down the violence, simplify[d] the Southern dialect, and delete[d] all derogatory references to Negroes. Given the degree and instances of irony and satire in the book, the difficult dialects and general reading level of the book, and the tendency of many students to read the book at the level of an adventure story, the committee believes, the novel requires more literary sophistication than can reasonably be expected from an average ninth grade student. Much emphasis is put onto the last several chapters of this meaningless great escape, an escape that would inevitably prove futile, and provide for an unclear ending, leaving readers to question, why all the fuss? The characterization of Jim is a string of inconsistencies. Huck and Jim 4. These students were also able to interpret the novel with greater literary sophistication than those students who read the novel without instruction. Therefore before desegregation white teachers taught the novel exclusively to white students.
Student cognitive and social maturity also takes on special significance in the face of such a complicated and subtle text.
There are many opportunists who acted quickly in this book and invited controversy and depict it inhumanely.
Petersburg, Missouri, and various other locations along the river through Arkansas. When judged at face value alone, this novel does indeed appear to be nothing but a bleak commentary about race relations in the s with overwhelmingly racist overtones.
The controversy of huckleberry finn essay
It don't seem natural, but I reckon it's so" chap. These views are both solid mainstays of modern literary criticism, and students would do well to begin considering them as early as high school. I wanted to sink into my seat. The actual matter and intent of the text are a source of contention. It must be understood, on the other hand, that the presence of incompetent, insensitive, or sometimes unwittingly, sometimes purposefully bigoted instructors in the public schools is no illusion. Since its first publication, Huck Finn has called a lot of controversy for a variety of reasons, including recent racial discrimination and accusation that the author himself is racist. Still, this novel has been the object of controversy since it was published more than years ago. Most scholars express opinions on whether or not to ban Huckleberry Finn in a paragraph or two of an article that deals mainly with another topic. Eliot, V. During the night, thinking that Huck is asleep, Jim vents the adult frustrations he does not expect Huck to understand or alleviate; he laments having to abandon his wife and two children: "Po' little Lizbeth! Racial Discourse 3. Instead, this should make it the pith of the American literature curriculum. Playing in the Dark. The volatile combination of satire, irony, and questions of race underscores an additional important facet of the controversy: teacher ability and attitude. Twain was not a fan of organized religion, and was known for his anti-slavery views.
Huckleberry Finn was first published in January of and only two months later in March of the book was banned. It closes our ears when we need to listen.
based on 33 review